One Liner: One of the finest country bands of all time
Home: Dallas (but of course likely Nashville now)
Poster Position: Headliner!
Then, here comes the name change and the very 2020 album. Even the title. Gaslighter. I really want to love this album, but after a handful of listens I'm pretty ambivalent about it. First off, this ain't country. And I know that shouldn't be surprising, they've been angling away from that work for a while, but the use of drum machines ("Julianna Calm Down," with a drum machine and forlorn organ instead of banjo and fiddle) and one song that is more or less a rap ("Tights on My Boat") are both surprising moves from these ladies. And I'm sure changing their name to step away from the potential racist connotations of "Dixie" is likewise carried along by distancing themselves from the country establishment in general. But more importantly, the album as a whole seems to be focused on personal issues, and less on the broadly pleasing story-telling, catchy tunes, and humor-with-insight that made them amazingly compelling back on their first two albums. I think back to "Wide Open Spaces" or "Goodbye Earl," and I'm immediately happy about the feelings those great songs evoke. But I think back to what I remember after 10 or so streams through this album and what I recall are Natalie's multiple mentions of some damn boat where her husband must have cheated on her. Which isn't really all that interesting in the end, except to the TMZ folks who want the tea spilled. And it's so specific - I can't relate to the issues they're singing about.
Their harmonies are still lovely. The banjo picking is still technically proficient and well-placed. But it feels like they put this out to show that they still aren't ready to make nice, but now none of us even remember why they were mad in the first place. The lead single and title track kind of bugs me - I think I'm tired of hearing the term gaslighting because I over-scroll Twitter - and I'm sure it was cathartic to Natalie to call out her ex-husband for being a lying jerk, but the song isn't catchy enough to make me want to dig in. And if it was catchy enough, then I could apply it to my own life - the liars that I might have to deal with - but in the end I just think about the dumb boat and that annoying term. That track is the top streamer on Spotify at 40.2 million streams, but I'm going to give you second place instead, "Sleep at Night," with 10.5 million.
The chorus makes me think of "HOW DO YA LIKE ME NOW!" from Toby Keith each time she sings it. Also, her ex-husband truly sounds like a piece of shit. Even if I don't much care about knowing about it. Maybe they'll release another album next that isn't quite so directly aimed at the balls of her old man. Despite not caring about the subject matter so much, that one is a good song. "Everybody Loves You" makes me think repeatedly of Coldplay - there is a piano lick lifted directly from "Trouble" and it throws me off each time. I know that "March March" is saying the word "march," but I keep hearing "Marge Marge" and I think of the Simpson's mom angrily marching down a Portland street to protest all of the random things that they sing about in this song. I think that normally I would gravitate to their big songs, but on this album, it's the quiet songs that are more appealing. But, despite really wishing that this was going to be the next big thing on my radar, I don't much care for this album. Hopefully something better is on the horizon.
Which makes me curious - what do their setlists look like these days? And the answer is kind of a bummer. Their last show had 10 tunes from Gaslighter, 4 covers, 3 each from Fly and Taking the Long Way, and 2 each from Home and Wide Open Spaces. Ruh roh. The show before that had one less cover and one less from Wide Open Spaces but was otherwise the same. Dang, seeing them at Red Rocks would have been dope. Their setlists look almost identical on this tour - Sin Wagon, Gaslighter, Texas Man, Juliana Calm Down, The Long Way Around... I guess my hope would be that they'll do a different show for a Festival crowd? Fingers crossed. I'm absolutely going to go see them - zero question in my mind - but I sure hope they go with the old tunes over the new disc.